Give the same brief to a maker, a skeptical customer and a scope cutter. Their disagreement is useful when it changes what you test.
1. Use one brief
Here is [idea, audience, evidence, available time]. Give me three separate notes. Maker: propose one version. Skeptical customer: explain why you might ignore it. Scope cutter: remove anything not needed to test the most important assumption.
2. Find the real disagreement
Compare the notes. Pick one disagreement that changes a decision. Name the assumptions on both sides and what evidence would resolve them. Treat the simulated customer view as a hypothesis, not research.
3. Make a test
Design one test with willing people from the intended audience, within [budget and time]. Give me one thing to show, one behavior to observe and one rule for keeping or changing the idea. Do not build or contact anyone.
Try it on one example
For a weekly planning template, test whether people reopen one page the next week before spending time polishing a bundle.
Inspired by Daily Team, a rotating creative-team experiment: https://github.com/isas1/daily-team.